The original text was published in Romanian, here: https://matcaliterara.ro/despre-cresterea-dreptei-radicale-fata-de-stanga-socialista-demontand-mitul-neomarxismului/
Introduction
A noticeable political phenomenon in Europe is that of the radical / populist right-wing parties that position themselves in opposition to the center formed by social democrats, moderate conservatives, and liberals. Much less relevant from an electoral point of view in most European countries are the radical / populist left-wing parties. This essay begins by debunking the myth promoted in Romania and other countries that European decision-making structures possess Neo-Marxist tendencies, explaining why it is in fact about progressive liberalism. The second part of the essay proposes two explanations, the first at the structural / systemic level, and the second at the political and social level, for why the new right-wing movements grow unilaterally in relation to those on the Left. The two explanations highlight, in an apparently paradoxical way, the dual nature of the Right, as both reactionary and as a movement of the status quo.
Clarifications on Neo-Marxism and Liberalism
At the institutional level in Europe, the influence of radical left-wing parties is much smaller than that of radical right-wing parties. But for the public opinion in Romania, for example, this may seem implausible, since in the public space the erroneous impression often is that the European Union possesses leftist tendencies of Neo-Marxist origin. After the collapse of the Soviet bloc, the political center of Europe on economic policy did not move to the left, but, on the contrary, to the right. Starting with the 1990s, the market economy together with political liberalism and the parliamentary regime (liberal democracy) were perceived as the models to follow, representing the apogee of social history. The post-socialist countries went through intense processes of liberalization, and in the West, the socialist parties gave up the model of massive intervention in the economy and planning, or projects of nationalization of industries, migrating moderately toward the neoliberal conventional wisdoms of free markets and globalization. The German SPD had given up the plans for industrial nationalization as early as 1959 with the adoption of the Godesberg Program, making the transition from Marxist socialism to social democracy, which accepted the social market economy. Over time, factors such as the disappearance or diminishing relevance of workers’ trade unions, the globalization of trade and capital flows, as well as the transition of European economies from industries to services determined the repositioning of social-democratic parties further to the right on the political spectrum, on economic issues. From this point of view, it is erroneous to speak about a left-shift of the center. The view that Europe is being eroded by a left also implies the social / cultural sphere. In the last two decades in Europe, policies of social inclusion, of promotion of diversity and multiculturalism, and ecological policies have been promoted into the mainstream. From this point of view, there is a turn in the sense that the traditional values of nation, family and faith have been eroded. But it is not about Neo-Marxism, but about progressive liberalism. In Romania, the opinion that this progressive current represents an erosion of liberalism is often promoted. On the contrary, if the theoretical foundations of liberalism, enunciated by John Locke, are taken ad literam, then no one has the right to harm the life, liberty or possessions of another.[1] The confusion comes from the fact that what is usually understood in Romania by liberalism is different from what is understood in the West. In Romania, liberalism is identified with free markets and the minimal state (the 19th century understanding), while in the West liberalism has also acquired progressive social and cultural values, which indeed undermine tradition. In terms of political classification, those who support free markets, the minimal state, but also tradition, are conservatives.[2]
One can speak about a social and cultural left-shift in Europe, but it is of liberal origin and much less Marxist. Without doubt, certain social groups identify as Neo-Marxist, but at the decision-making level there is no significant representation along this line. It is true that in Western academia Marxism, postcolonialism, feminism etc. are studied, but at the level of the European establishment, it is not these that influence public policies, but progressive liberalism. Any Neo-Marxist vision must address the problem of the tension between classes (racially, gender-based or economically) in a systemic manner, offering a critique of capitalism and advocating for an alternative, while the European mainstream, through its inclusion policies within the capitalist system, is progressive-liberal, not Neo-Marxist. On the contrary, the latter theory is used in academia to criticize liberalism, even the progressive one. It is arguably false to speak about a leftism of Marxist origin strongly institutionalized in Europe. Nor can one speak in the USA about a strong leftism in political institutions. There are public figures, such as Bernie Sanders or Zohran Mamdani, who indeed are much further to the left than the American average, but at the decision-making level left-wing visions are mostly marginal. Most of those who are labeled as leftists or “woke-ists” are progressive liberals in European definitions. Even if one cannot speak about an institutionalized Neo-Marxist current, neither in Europe nor in the USA, the term usually being used for the purpose of political propaganda, for delegitimization, one can, however, without doubt discuss a cultural struggle between progressives / liberals and conservatives.
That being said, in Romania there is neither authentic Neo-Marxism nor progressivism, at least not comparable to the understanding in the West. In the public sphere political struggles are often presented as being between progressives and conservatives. But Romania is a deeply conservative country, and those who are called progressives are usually the people who ask for administrative changes, without advocating for a cultural or ideological change at the level of behavior and beliefs, at least not to the extent that the term requires. As a concrete example, in PNL (National Liberal Party) there is often talk of a progressive wing and a conservative wing. One cannot speak about progressivism in PNL, as long as it remains a conservative party, which defends Christian and national values. No one among the powerful people in this party asks for a transformation in the sense of giving up support for traditional values. In PNL there is a reformist wing, or one that advocates for administrative change, and a wing that wants business as usual. Generalizing, what in the public sphere is denounced as a struggle at the institutional level between progressives and conservatives is nothing but a collision between people who advocate for a different way of doing politics[3] and those who defend the status quo, business as usual.
The Unilateral Growth of the Right versus the Left
Now that we have established definitional aspects and explained why one cannot speak about Neo-Marxism at the level of the European establishment, the asymmetric growth of the radical right in relation to the radical left can be addressed. One often hears about the rise of the extremes and the erosion of the center. Most of the time it is about radical right-wing movements gaining ground against the centrist tandem occupied by the social-democratic center-left and the conservative center-right. In the understanding of this essay, the radical right is defined as a movement that advocates strict respect of traditional values, harsh anti-immigration policies towards non-European people and a certain degree of Euroscepticism, especially towards federalization. These include parties and movements such as AfD (Alternative für Deutschland), from Germany, the National Rally (Rassemblement National), from France, Reform UK, or Fratelli D’Italia, from Italy. The radical left is defined as a movement that advocates stronger state control in the economy, the nationalization of some industries and publicly funded social programs (we can call it the socialist or anti-capitalist left). These include the socialist parties in European countries, most of which, however, do not pass the minimum threshold to enter parliament. I choose not to use the term extreme in either case,[4] the overall phenomenon observed being the rebirth and unilateral growth in popularity of some new right-wing parties, some more radical than others, without a similar reaction on the left. The parties mentioned above have trajectories and evolutions that differ, and the simple labeling as “extremist” parties is not useful for an analysis. For example, Giorgia Meloni’s party, Fratelli D’Italia, became much more moderate after becoming institutionalized on a European and local level. This process of moderation is sometimes called “Melonization”. The rest of the parties not being in government, it is premature to decide how “extremist” each one really is. The question that must be asked is the following: once they enter government, will the state apparatus and the rule of law be strong enough to moderate these parties, or will they succeed in eroding its functioning? Unlike the Meloni case in Italy, in Hungary governed by Fidesz and in Poland governed by PiS, the parties captured state institutions in the detriment of democracy.
The first explanation for the problem of the asymmetric rise of the Right compared to the Left is a structural one, focusing strictly on the systemic analysis of society, and shows why the Right, from this point of view, is the movement of the status quo. The second explanation is concrete, at the social surface, bringing to light the reactionary character of the new European right-wing movements.
From the definitions one can notice a fundamental difference. The Right mostly has a social focus, and the Left has an economic focus. This fact leads to a first factor that encourages the asymmetric growth between the two, a structural factor: the capitalist market economy. The market economy brings with it a certain type of social relations, a certain way of relating to ourselves, to those around us and to the surrounding nature. In a capitalist system, a left-wing movement is by its own nature reactionary, going against the current. From the start it begins with a handicap, the very structure of the social system in which it exists being opposed to it at the level of principle and operation. The Right starts with an advantage because the institutions of the free market and private property are internalized / reified. Consequently, the Right will manifest itself on the socially, already holding the economic, while the Left starts from the base, proposing systemic, anti-capitalist changes. A conservative movement, therefore, forms naturally in a capitalist economy, being an exponent of the structures in society; it is a movement of the status quo. On the other hand, to propagate to the masses, a left-wing movement has as its aim the denaturalization / dereification of the economic and social ideas internalized in a capitalist society. This process requires promotion, mass organization and financial efforts, being combated by conservative groups. In addition, after the Covid-19 pandemic, increasingly larger percentages of the population report feelings of loneliness and lack of social connection.[5] This added factor hinders the propagation of left-wing ideas even more. Fundamental to these are the creation of a feeling of belonging and identification to the social class among people, a solidarity, and if people feel increasingly disconnected from their own society, it is very hard for a project of this type to have results. In this social context, much more prominent and at hand in the collective mind are traditional values, identification with the nation, faith and tradition, therefore with conservative elements. This is the first structural, systemic reason why right-wing movements are born much more easily than left-wing ones in a capitalist market economy.
Nowadays, the rise of the radical right is to a good extent also a reaction to globalization. In the absence of something of one’s own in a digital, fluid and increasingly unpredictable world, historical memory and nationalism together with tradition become references for navigation. The internationalism of the left is too far from the ordinary man in an already globalized world. The nation, the family and faith thus become the landmarks that give meaning and direction. Exacerbated nationalism thus becomes a reaction to global capitalism that does not take borders into account. The American philosopher Nancy Fraser introduced the term cannibal capitalism, a stage of capitalism in which the logic of profit destroys the very foundations that allowed the creation of capitalist societies (hence the term cannibal). In this case, neoliberal capitalism, by encouraging globalization, undermines the nation-states, which in past centuries were the ones that laid the foundations of the institutions of the market and private property. On top of this, massive immigration from the non-European space modifies the demography and social relations in European states. Numerous groups of people oppose these changes, appealing to the preservation of Western civilization. The phenomenon of immigration from the non-European space has not only accentuated the rise of the right in the last decade, but has also united the different movements through a common struggle. The right’s discourse on the topic of immigration is not particularist, but collectivist, claiming the heritage of a European civilization built over thousands of years. The left remains a mere passive observer or commentator of these trends, going against the current in its vision of the nation-state, borders and immigration. From this point of view, the radical right is not a movement of the status quo, but a social reaction to the direction the Western world has taken in the last decades, combining in a nostalgic way, but one that seems revolutionary, belonging to the nation, the social role of traditional values and identification with the Christian faith.
Conclusion
One cannot speak about Neo-Marxism at the level of the European establishment, because on the economic plane the center has migrated to the right in the last decades, and on the social and cultural plane the changes derive from progressive liberalism, not from Neo-Marxism. The causes for which the new radical right-wing movements grow asymmetrically compared to those of the left have social roots and structural causes. The logical architecture of this essay is designed to highlight the dual nature of the right (supporter of the status quo, but also reactionary), which, although I consider it useful, has its limitations. For example, against the first argument, one can counter-argue that there were long periods in which left-wing parties, social-democratic but also socialist, were in government, even in a market economy, such as in the Nordic countries or in the Europe of the first decades of the 20th century, through the social / welfare state. And against the second proposed argument, one can counter-argue that economic insecurity (this refers to economic inequalities, the urban – rural discrepancy, differences in career opportunities, uncertainty at the workplace etc.) would be a stronger correlate than cultural / social factors with the rise of the new right-wing movements.
[1]Section 6, Chapter II, Two Treatises of Government. It is interesting to note the fact that Locke uses negation and not affirmation, appealing to what Isaiah Berlin calls negative liberty. In other words, the liberty referred to is about not being constrained from the outside, not about being able to do anything.
[2]The name PNL (National Liberal Party) is unsuitable for the party for the reasons stated above, it being rather a conservative party. As proof, it is part of the European People’s Party (predominantly conservative), not of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe. USR (Save Romania Union) is the party in Romania that can be called a liberal party, on both the social and economic issues.
[3]Personally, I do not agree with equating change with reform. The term reform has a positive connotation, but at the moment of implementation change does not show its effects. The qualitative evaluation of the proposed change, by which it is decided whether it was beneficial, is retrospective. Therefore, at the moment of implementation, one cannot know whether the change brings the desired positive effects. In addition, the metric of benefits can also be subjective and ideologized.
[4]Often the label of extremist is used in a propagandistic way, with a delegitimizing purpose, cancelling the possibility of debate. Romania is not an exception in this sense either. The term radical suggests orientation either more to the left or more to the right, in relation to the center.
[5] https://op.europa.eu/en/publication-detail/-/publication/67ee8c53-edcc-11eb-a71c-01aa75ed71a1/language-en; https://www.americansurveycenter.org/research/the-state-of-american-friendship-change-challenges-and-loss/
